By May 2026, the Pretoria High Court is hearing one of the most consequential legal challenges South Africa’s profession has seen in years. Major firms, Bowmans, Webber Wentzel, and Werksmans, are arguing that the new Legal Sector B-BBEE Code is “unlawful and unworkable.” On the other side, the Black Lawyers Association and transformation advocates are saying the legal profession has had 30 years and has moved far too slowly.
If you are a law firm owner, a Black attorney building your practice, or a business that relies on legal services, and you find yourself confused about who is right here, that is not surprising at all. This debate is genuinely complex, and the noise around it makes it harder, not easier, to understand what is actually at stake for you.
Here is the thing that cuts through that noise: almost nobody in this courtroom is arguing that transformation is wrong. What is being fought over is whether this particular code will actually deliver transformation, or whether it is so structurally compromised that it will produce the opposite. That matters, because it moves the conversation away from “transformation vs. resistance” and into a more honest question: what does good transformation policy actually look like?
The Real Tension: Genuine Intent, Competing Outcomes
The Minister’s office gazetted this code months after taking office. Advocate Tembeka Ngcukaitobi, a name that carries serious weight in South African constitutional law, is leading the argument that the Minister did not “meaningfully apply his mind” to the thousands of objections raised by the industry before signing it into law. That is not a small procedural complaint. It goes to the heart of whether the code is legally defensible.
At the same time, the Black Lawyers Association is correct that the legal profession remains one of the least transformed sectors three decades into democracy. That is a fact that should sit uncomfortably with everyone, including the large firms now in court.
Both of those things can be true. And for small and mid-sized Black-owned law firms, the tension between them is not academic. It is immediately practical.
Three Things the Code Gets Wrong That Actually Hurt Transformation
This is where the debate gets interesting, and where many commentators miss the mark.
The first problem is the timeline. The code demands 50% Black ownership within five years. The typical path to equity partnership in a law firm is ten to eleven years of merit-based progression. You cannot compress that in half the time without either forcing buyouts that new partners cannot afford, or creating “paper ownership” structures that tick a compliance box while changing nothing real. That kind of tokenism is not transformation. It is the appearance of it.
The second problem is who counts. The code only recognises practising lawyers toward ownership and management scores. This means a Black Chief Financial Officer, a Black Head of Human Resources, or a Black Chief Technology Officer at a multi-billion-rand firm counts for nothing in the compliance calculation. These are senior professionals driving real business decisions every day. Excluding them is not a minor technical oversight. It is a design flaw that actively devalues Black talent in non-legal roles.
The third problem is what the code removes. Previous codes gave firms credit for bursaries and skills development, the pipeline that produces Black candidate attorneys in the first place. This code heavily discounts or removes that recognition entirely. If you stop rewarding firms for funding the pipeline, fewer firms will fund it, and the long-term supply of Black legal professionals shrinks. That is the opposite of what transformation should achieve.
What This Means for Your Firm Right Now
For firms currently holding Level 1 B-BBEE status under the generic codes, the new sector code could drop them to Level 6 or lower. That is not just a reputational issue. It is a commercial one. Government work and major bank panels often require a minimum B-BBEE level to participate, and billions in contracts are potentially affected.
For mid-sized firms, the new code lowered the “large entity” threshold from R50 million to R25 million. Many firms that were previously measured under lighter compliance requirements now face the full weight of the strictest category. Some experts believe this will drive mergers or closures among firms that simply cannot absorb the compliance costs.
For young Black attorneys and candidate attorneys, the uncertainty around how this plays out affects the very opportunities the code is supposed to create.
The Question Worth Asking
The constitutional validity argument around “race quotas” is live in court, and it will be decided by the judiciary. But the more practical question, the one that affects you whether the code survives or not, is this: is your firm’s transformation strategy built on sustainable, verifiable foundations, or is it built around whatever the current compliance framework says?
A compliance-first approach to transformation is fragile. It shifts every time the code changes, which, as this court case shows, happens more often than anyone plans for. A strategy built on genuine ownership structures, real skills pipelines, and documented management participation is one that holds up regardless of what the court decides.
We Help Firms Build What Lasts
Our team works with law firms, professional service providers, and businesses navigating B-BBEE compliance. Not just to get the score right, but to make sure the structure behind the score is legally sound and commercially sustainable. We have seen too many firms build ownership arrangements that look good on paper and collapse at the first audit or ownership dispute.
Whether your concern right now is understanding how the court’s outcome affects your current rating, restructuring your equity arrangements ahead of potential regulatory changes, or simply getting a second opinion on whether your current B-BBEE strategy is actually working, we can help you think it through.
There is no cost to that first consulation. Visit us at ombaloyi.co.za and let us talk through where you are and what makes sense for your firm.
Get in touch with us
If you want to work with a law firm that is up to date with the latest practices, reach out to us by leaving your details.